Concerning Israel’s rejection of the gospel in the days of the Apostles, Rom. 9-11 generally give us three statements: Israel’s rejection is not God’s fault (Ch. 9), Israel’s rejection is Israel’s fault (Ch. 10), and Israel’s rejection is not the end of the story (Ch. 11). First, consider Rom. 9:1-29.
· Paul grieved for Israel, 9:1-5. He even wished it were possible that he could be “accursed from Christ” for his brethren. It is important to note that Paul is talking about “my brethren, my countrymen according to the flesh, who are Israelites.” He is talking about the nation, God’s “special treasure above all the peoples on the face of the earth” (Deut. 7:6). The nation of Israel was the recipient of many blessings from God, chief of which was that Christ came as an Israelite when He dwelt among us. You might want to think that God failed in some way, having given Israel all these benefits and yet still seeing them reject His Son, the Messiah. Thus, Paul makes it clear: God did not fail Israel.
· God’s word was not ineffective, 9:6-13. God’s choice of the nation came in three stages: first He chose Abraham (Gen. 18:10,14), then Abraham’s son Isaac (Gen. 21:12), and then Isaac’s son Jacob (Gen. 25:23; in this it was said that God hated Esau and loved Jacob, Malachi 1:2-3). You can read in the OT and see in the Gospels and Acts that God’s choice did not fail. The chosen people are not from Ishmael or Esau. They are from Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. But don’t miss 9:6: For they are not all Israel who are of Israel. This is a theme Paul raised in Rom. 2:28-29: … he is not a Jew who is one outwardly … but he is a Jew who is one inwardly … whose praise is not from men but from God. Keep this in mind as you read through these chapters.
· God’s choice was not unfair, 9:14-18. Was God unfair (unrighteous) to choose Jacob and not Esau? No! Not any more than He used Pharoah for His purposes in the time of the Exodus. It is important to note that God’s choice of Jacob over Esau, and His use of Pharoah, is not saying that He chose one for salvation and the other damnation. These choices had to do with the nation Israel. Ishmael, Esau and Pharoah could have at some point put their faith in the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. But they were appointed by God for the role they played in His choice of one nation.
· God’s plan is being fulfilled, 9:19-29. The bottom line is that God made choices (election), and He has that right as the Creator, the “potter.” He had a reason, which ultimately is to bring glory to Himself. He poured out His wrath on Pharaoh and Egypt so that He might be exalted among the people of Israel, and the world. In the same way, His choice of Israel did not mean that all Israelites would be saved (remember v6: they are not all Israel who are of Israel) nor did it mean that no Gentiles would be saved (v24-29).


